All StoresGoodfellas Pizza Orlando CouponsGoodfellas Pizza Orlando Store

Goodfellas Pizza Orlando Reviews

4.7

(Rated by 12 users)

Store Details & Policies

Customer Reviews Store Information Features & Analysis FAQs

Overall Rating

4.7

Base on 12 Reviews

Ratings by Feature

Good Value
4.5
Price & Quality
4.5
Customer Service
5.0
Return Policy
4.8
Shipping & Delivery
4.0

Recent Customer Reviews (12)

Joel Byrne

Oct 9, 2025

View replies

Mavise Migneault

Oct 7, 2025

View replies

Nóra Pataki

Oct 7, 2025

View replies

Thomas Bentley

Oct 6, 2025

View replies

Sarah Adams

Oct 5, 2025

View replies

Melissa Wells

Oct 4, 2025

View replies

Chad Losey

Oct 4, 2025

View replies

Ruth Collum

Oct 4, 2025

View replies

Tony Garza

Oct 3, 2025

View replies

Jody Marquis

Oct 2, 2025

View replies

Load More Reviews

Store Policies

Free Shipping: No
Delivery Time: No
International Shipping: No
In-Store Pickup: Yes
Day Returns: No
Birthday Discounts: No
Loyalty Program: Yes
Warranty: No
Money-Back Guarantee: No

Price Ranges

Wings (Build Your Own): $17.95 - $36.95
Build Your Own Pizza: $11.99 - $23.99
Cheese Pizza: $11.99 - $23.99
Pepperoni Pizza: $13.99 - $28.99
Goodfella's Special Pizza: $15.95 - $31.95
Bianca Pizza: $15.95 - $33.95
Bianca with Spinach Pizza: $16.95 - $34.95
Vegetarian Pizza: $15.95 - $32.95
Hawaiian Pizza: $14.95 - $31.95
Goodfella's Deluxe Calzone: $16.95 - $27.95
Strombolis Small: $10.95 - $14.95
Strombolis Large: $16.95 - $21.95
Calzones: $10.95 - $15.95

Goodfellas Pizza Orlando Reviews

Payment Methods

Payment Methods

Overall Rating

Ratings by Feature

Ratings by Feature

Recent Customer Reviews (12)

Joel Byrne

Mavise Migneault

Nóra Pataki

Thomas Bentley

Sarah Adams

Melissa Wells

Chad Losey

Ruth Collum

Tony Garza

Jody Marquis

Goodfellas Pizza Orlando Pricing

Wings (Build Your Own)

Build Your Own Pizza

Cheese Pizza

Pepperoni Pizza

Goodfella's Special Pizza

Bianca Pizza

Bianca with Spinach Pizza

Vegetarian Pizza

Hawaiian Pizza

Goodfella's Deluxe Calzone

Strombolis Small

Strombolis Large

Calzones

Goodfellas Pizza Orlando Pros & Cons

Pros

CONS

Goodfellas Pizza Orlando Features and Benefits

Features

Authentic New York-style Italian cuisine

Online ordering for pickup and delivery

Reward points system

Welcoming atmosphere

Amazing food, excellent service, and popular catering options

Broad menu

Long-standing reputation

Consistently good pizza and pasta

Pleasant atmosphere

Good service experiences

Fresh food

Goodfellas Pizza Orlando Frequently Asked Questions